Office hours 000-000-0000
A close crop of a gear lever in neutral, the gaiter plain and the knob unmarked

The journal

Automatic or manual, and what the restriction actually means

A test taken in an automatic gives you a licence with a restriction on it. Here is what that does and does not stop you doing.

  • five minute read
  • Written at the school, not bought in

The choice, stated plainly

Almost everybody who learns here learns in an automatic and takes the road test in one. The school keeps one manual car for the people who do not want that, and this article is for deciding which of those two you are.

A road test taken in an automatic gives you a licence with an automatic restriction on it. That restriction is the State's, it is printed on the licence, and it means the licence is not valid for a car you have to shift yourself.

We are not going to paraphrase the exact wording of a restriction on your own licence, or tell you what it takes to have one removed. That is on the State's own licence-class page and it is precisely the sort of rule that is worth reading rather than being told about. Licence classes and restrictions at the DMV (opens dmv.ny.gov in a new tab)

What the restriction does not stop you doing

  • Driving any automatic car, which in this country is the ordinary kind. A manual lesson is a rare product wherever it is sold and is usually priced above an ordinary one, which tells you how often the transmission actually comes up here.
  • Getting your learner permit, sitting the written test, or taking the five-hour pre-licensing course. None of those has anything to do with which pedals the car has.
  • Choosing where you test, booking your own appointment, or turning up in any car that meets the State's requirements for a test vehicle.
  • Changing your mind later. Learning a manual after you hold a licence is an ordinary thing that people do, and it is easier than learning both at once — it is only the licence that has a restriction on it, not you.

What it does stop you doing

Driving a manual car on that licence. Which is a small thing until it is not, and here are the four cases where it is not:

  • There is already a manual car in the household

    The commonest one by a distance. A family with one manual car and a newly licensed driver who cannot legally drive it has bought a problem, and usually finds out about it a week after the licence arrives.

  • Work will hand you one

    Vans, small lorries and older fleet cars are far more likely to be manual than a private car is. If a job might involve driving something the employer owns, ask before you book a test rather than after.

  • You will hire cars abroad

    Outside this country the manual is often the default and always the cheaper booking. A restricted licence turns that into a more expensive holiday every time.

  • You want an older or a smaller car

    The second-hand end of the market has more manuals in it than the new one does, and a restriction quietly removes a slice of what you can shop for.

The honest trade-off

A first hour with a clutch is a short hour. Finding a biting point eats the beginning of it, and the rest goes on hill starts and on not stalling at junctions. That is why this school books manual lessons as extended lessons of an hour and a half rather than standard lessons of one hour: not to sell you a longer lesson, but because the shorter one does not contain a useful amount of driving.

An hour and a half costs what it costs, and it is a real difference in the bill. The figures are on the prices page, printed beside the number of lessons and the length of each, and we would rather you compared them before you decided than discovered them afterwards.

It will probably take more lessons, not fewer. And the road test is the same test with one more thing to get wrong in it. A hill start is a different hill start with an examiner beside you.

Against all that: it is far easier to learn now, while everything is new and nothing is a habit yet, than to come back to it in five years with a licence you do not want to put at risk.

How to decide, in two lists

Learn in the manual if

  • Somebody in the household drives one, or the car you will actually use is one.
  • Your work might hand you a van or anything with a fleet badge on the key.
  • You expect to hire cars in countries where the manual is the default.
  • You would rather hold a licence with nothing written on it, and you are not in a hurry.

Learn in an automatic if

  • You want to be driving sooner rather than later, for a job or for a family reason.
  • Everything you are likely to be handed to drive is automatic, and you have checked rather than assumed it.
  • You are nervous. A clutch is one more thing to be nervous about, and the nerves cost more hours than the transmission saves.
  • You are coming back to driving after years away and want the road back first.

Not a ruling. Neither list is advice about your licence. Which restriction ends up printed on it, and what removes one, is the State's business and is worth reading on the State's page before you book a test in either car.

The car, and who teaches in it

A manual car, for drivers who want the licence without the automatic restriction. A dual-control clutch as well as a brake — so the instructor can stop the car and can take the clutch out of your hands, which is why a first hour with one is less alarming than it sounds.

Marta Oyelaran teaches it. Marta teaches the manual car and takes most of the school's nervous and returning drivers. Her first lesson with a nervous driver is often a stationary one, and she says so before it is booked rather than after.

She works Monday to Friday, 8 am to 4 pm. There is one manual car, so a manual lesson is one diary rather than four, and it is worth booking a little further ahead than an automatic lesson needs.

What a manual lesson actually covers

What is fitted to the school's cars

Two more, while you are here

Six pieces about learning to drive in this borough, written by the people who teach it.

All six in the journal

Ready to book a lesson?

Reserve a package and it becomes credits. Then pick an instructor, a date and a time out of the real diary, and give us the address to pick you up from. Nothing is paid on this website.